Monday, January 28, 2013

You hate me because I'm SKINNY


By: Luz Garcia

Ever since I began writing I've wanted to write about this topic, but I never did because I didn't want to put my insecurities out there. I wanted to write about this topic when I came to terms with who I am and what I look like because it's hard to admit to anyone that you may feel self-conscience about yourself. Today, I feel like I have learned to embrace me and my body and can now tackle the issue head-on for the sake of skinny girls like me!

I cannot even begin to explain how many Tweets, Facebook statuses, and hundreds of articles bashing skinny girls I see on a daily basis. I guess it's the new IT thing. It's disgusting to think that one group of women has to put another group of women down to feel better about themselves.

Some women, like myself, are naturally thin. Yes, I eat. Yes, I'd love to gain weight. I've tried my whole life to have thick sexy legs. But my frame was built tiny and no matter how much I try I may never achieve those legs. And just like heavier girls, I've been teased too. Skinny girls can't help being skinny any more than overweight girls can help being overweight. We're both human, and we're both vulnerable.

I've never understood the double standard.
Why is it insulting to call a person fat, but okay to call a person a stick? Why can't you tell a fat person to go on a diet, but you can tell a skinny person to eat something? Why is it taboo to say she looks obese because you can sorta see a gut, but okay to point out that she looks anorexic because you can sorta see her ribs? Do skinny girls not have feelings?

Media influence...
has a lot to do with these anti-skinny sentiments. The media has un-deliberately vilified thin women by holding them responsible for society's beauty standards, and accusing models for example, of having eating disorders and setting a bad example for girls everywhere (I'd like to point out that not everyone who is thin has an eating disorder). To counter that, many campaigns like Dove have risen to promote "healthier" body types.


I'm all up for campaigning to promote self confidence. But let me address the campaign methods and how they contradict themselves.


"Real women have curves" Dove has used it in its Real Beauty Campaign and it's one of the most used quotes when showing support to women who are... well, curvier.

Technically all women have curves, big or small, they're there; curves are a part of all feminine silhouettes, but people have taken this quote that's meant to celebrate women of ALL body types out of context; instead they use it to support all body types THAT ARE NOT thin types, because apparently if you're thin, you don't have any curves. Hence, you are not a real woman. Sorry.

But last time I checked I seemed to have all of the attributes that would classify me a woman, and I feel like a woman. Oh darn! I forgot I don't have "curves" because... well, that's just been genetically impossible for me. Damn you fast metabolism! Now I can't ever be considered a REAL woman. I guess all there's left to do is to pretend being one.

Another one is "Being skinny is not good, being healthy is." Many girls that are skinny believe it or not, are in fact, healthy.

And of course one of my personal least favorites, "Men like women with meat on their bones" Hmmm odd that a woman is telling me this (because 89.6% of the time it is a woman) seeing it as she is in no way a man and has no right to generalize the personal taste in women of all men. In my personal experience, and mind you I'm very thin, I haven't had too much of a rough time finding a date. I'm pretty sure I win them over with my amazing personality :D  but some of them have actually told me that they are attracted to me [insert surprised emoticon here]. And they are REAL men. Crazy... I know. There are tastes for everyone, some like thick girls, others prefer them thin. Who woulda thought?

Most of these "confidence boosters" are counterproductive. They enhance one groups confidence while they scrutinize and put down another's.

Then there are the myths...
the ones that make people think that thin people are "lucky" for.
All clothes fitting. False. Along with, all clothes look good on you. False.
Growing up, my mom along with mothers of skinny daughters all over the world, had the hardest time finding clothes, more specifically bottoms that fit. So all of my skirts and pants had to be taken in. Sometimes smalls are too big because contrary to popular belief smalls are made for girls that are size 3 and up. So if you are a size 0-2 tough luck. Now all grown up, some jeans are just hard to fill, and good luck shopping for dresses!

Articles like "10 things I hate about skinny people" don't help our cause. Going down the list they all seem like ridiculous reasons to me but I'll address #6 on here since I find it to be a common misconception.

6.  "They don’t feel compelled to finish all the food on their plate. When they’re full, they’re full. They don’t eat a single bite after they make this announcement. In return, we end up eating their leftovers.”

Wow, couldn't be any more wrong! It's actually very awkward when you as a thin person only want to order a salad, or can't finish everything on your plate. Thin people, for the most part feel like they have to prove to everyone that they are healthy and not anorexic, just because there's always that stigma. Therefore, if we find ourselves in a situation where you have to sit and eat it in public, with someone else that we may not feel too comfortable with, we feel as if we HAVE to finish everything to avoid hearing comments like "that's why you're so skinny, you don't eat." One too many times I found myself over-eating just so that people wouldn't judge me if I didn't finish my plate.

In conclusion...
not everyone who is thin wants to be, just like not everyone who is overweight wants to be either.
Messages like the ones I just discussed are in the public eye everyday, and sometimes we think them, and sometimes we say them; and we don't know how they will affect the receiving end. Commenting on a person's weight is not okay, unless it is a positive comment or if it is a serious matter of concern, and if that's the case then tact and courtesy is crucial.

If you have to put someone down to validate your own weight then there's a deeper self-esteem issue lying there. Instead of worrying about others focus on yourself. Work on the body you want to achieve. A body that you believe is healthy for you, because what may be healthy for you may not be healthy for others. You're only given one life, and in that life only one body to go through it with, so love the body you're in.

I love mine, and I think it's beautiful.

13 comments:

  1. Hi,

    in general: great blog post. As a plus girl fighting other people´s stupid ideas about my body most of my life, I completely agree that body hate has to stop. Every type of body hate. Now.
    Women are gorgeous in every size, and I absolutely agree that skinny bashing is a stupid as fat bashing.

    One thing I am not too happy about, and I read this in a lot of "stop skinny bashing" posts and blogs is this: you write "Why can't you tell a fat person to go on a diet, but you can tell a skinny person to eat something? Why is it taboo to say she looks obese because you can sorta see a gut, but okay to point out that she looks anorexic because you can sorta see her ribs?".

    Thing is, the way you put it it seems that bashing plus people has suddenly become a taboo, and people would suddenly be kind to bigger folk.
    Truth is: they are not. To many, many people, fat bashing is NOT a taboo, and they will tell anyone whom they consider fat to go on a diet. There is still more fat-bashing than skinny-bashing out there (again, I am againg all kind of body-bashing, and I do not want to say a fat girl being bullied suffers more than a skinny one).

    I just feel that many stop skinnybashing bloggers and posters inadvertedly try to portraid a world where fatbashing has suddenly stopped and skinnybashing is all the rage, resulting in new double standards.
    The sad truth is: yes, skinny bashing seems to be more popular there days. That does not say fatbashing has stopped. It has not.

    And that is the problem.

    As long as bodybashing exists in any form, insecure people will lash out agaings body types unlike their own. Very often, because they themselves have been criticised a lot, because their own boundaries have been overstepped dozens of times.
    So, what can we do? Unite and stand up. Big girls speaking up for our thinner sisters.
    But thin girls have to do that, too. Stop the bashing of bigger girls.
    To stop the culture of body-bashing forever!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your feedback Rhealicious.

      You bring up a great point. Fat bashing has not gone away, it’s still a problem in society, but this particular blog is based on the growing skinny bashing trend. Truth is, whether it is taboo or not, people who are mean-spirited will comment on anyone big or small.

      However, my own personal experiences and people I’ve encountered support a lot of the things stated on this personal blog entry. And I can only speak, or in this case write, about what I know. I have been in more situations where bashing my body type has been for the most part okay. For example a friend will be quick to tell me that I’m too skinny, but she won’t tell our other mutual friend that they need to lose weight because she is afraid of “hurting her feelings,” those are the situations I’m talking about.

      That being said, I totally agree with you. Body bashing in general has to stop. And yes, we must all unite and celebrate all body types because in the end, big or small, we’re all women and in this society that’s already a mission on its own.

      I just think we need to find different methods to promote self-confidence equally where we don't make one group, whether it’s the bigger or the smaller one, feel better by alienating the other.

      Again, thank you so much for your comment. Seeing other perspectives always help a writer keep grounded. Peace and love.

      Delete
  2. "Smalls are made for girls that are size 3 and up. So if you are a size 0-2 tough luck. Now all grown up, some jeans are just hard to fill, and good luck shopping for dresses!"

    OMG!!!!!! Thank you! I have the same issue. I told my friend this (she wears size 17+ jeans) and she thought I was lying, complaining, and bragging! Skinny women have problems just like anyone else when finding clothes. It is not a bed of roses. She said it is easy to find skinny clothes. Um, are you blind? Try finding a 00 jeans! It's easier finding average size pants, what is she talking about? There are plus size stores too. I hate the double standards.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know exactly what you mean. 00 and 0 are tough finds!

      Delete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. MariPily, I felt bad/sorry for myself for so long, I honestly hated being so skinny. Now I'm just happy that I'm healthy. I hope you have learned to love your body. You are beautiful no matter what your weight. Health is what make a person beautiful.

      Delete
  4. hi im a 55 kg male im half the size of every one i know i was picked on all thought out high school as well as primary school all 12 year's of schooling i have been trying to put on weight for the past 3 year's and have been smaller then every one else my hole life and most of my best mate's are just over 100 kg and tell me how they wish they were me when in fact i wish i could be alot bigger so at least then i could have a fighting chance at defending my self

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My brother inherited the same genes I did, he is very thin like me. I understand what you mean. I think that weight pressure is there for men too. I hope you reach your goal weight, regardless, remember you are unique and there are many people who indeed wish they could have your body size. Thank you for commenting.

      Delete
  5. Great read with great points ... bashing one type to lift another isn't gonna help anyone- if you need to put down someone different to make yourself feel better, that's not granting you real confidence at all.

    Body categorising is so stupid. Small, skinny girls can actually be really curvy. And thicker, bigger girls can actually not be as 'curvy' like an hourglass figure. There are just so many body shapes anyway it's ignorant to make it about 'skinny VS curvy/fat' or 'bones VS meat' (who comes up with this stupid shit?? really, everyone has bones and meat otherwise they wouldn't be alive)

    People can debate whether it's easier or harder for skinnier girls or bigger girls in whatever context, but you can't argue that an insult is an insult. People need to lay off criticising other people's bodies for whatever reasons and just be cool with the idea that more than one kind, in fact- all kinds of body types - can be great!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well stated! Agreed! Girl power! No matter what your weight is! Thank you for reading!

      Delete
  6. Hello there! If you have problems finding clothes your size, have you tried Asian retailers? I'm a size 00 so Asian clothes fit better.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I am fifteen years of age going on sixteen. From grade four continuing on now people have accused me of being on crack-cocaine or being afflicted with anorexia nervosa. I have tried eating everything, working out, everything with the exception of drugs and plastic surgery. My skinniness is hereditary, nearly everyone in my family is small or petite. I can't wear a lot of what I like because I'm afraid people will think I'm showing off. Life is difficult for everyone so why can't we just chill the hell out and get along, or at least not give people crap for being different. Because in many cases, whether you're muscular, overweight, underweight, or anything in between we can't help it. Don't people think that if I could gain weight I would.

    ReplyDelete